Cricut vs Sizzix - Which Die Cut Machine Is Better?
This post contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you if you click through the link and make a purchase. For more information, click here.
As someone who has owned both the Cricut Maker and the Sizzix Big Shot since 2021, I have had the opportunity to compare these two popular die cut machines. I primarily use these machines for cutting felt craft projects, so I have been able to test out their features and capabilities extensively. When comparing the Cricut Maker and the Sizzix Big Shot, there are certainly pros and cons to consider. The Cricut Maker is known for its precision and versatility, with the ability to cut a wide range of materials and intricate designs. On the other hand, the Sizzix Big Shot is praised for its durability and ease of use. Both machines have their unique strengths, making it challenging to declare one as definitively better than the other. Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on individual crafting needs and preferences. Let's explore Cricut vs Sizzix in more detail.
Happy Crafting with Die Cutting Machines!
Having the right tools for felt will help you to enjoy the felt crafting hobby even more. You might be interested in reading the following sewing tips and tricks posts as well:
Table of Content
Cricut and Sizzix are both companies that specialize in selling die cut machines used for cutting out intricate designs on various materials. Both companies are based in the United States, with Sizzix located in California and Cricut headquartered in Utah. Cricut is dedicated to empowering creativity and providing innovative tools for DIY creators to bring their ideas to life. On the other hand, Sizzix focuses on inspiring a fun and memorable making experience, specifically emphasizing creating a vibrant and diverse community of crafters. It is also worth noting that Sizzix is a women-led business, which adds to its unique perspective and approach in the industry. Both companies are beloved by crafters worldwide for their high-quality products and commitment to innovation.
Cricut Maker vs Sizzix Big Shot
Cricut Maker and its Features
The Cricut Maker is an electronic cutting machine from Cricut. It is the perfect tool for crafters and DIY enthusiasts who want to cut various materials with precision and ease. Its adaptive tool system allows for cutting hundreds of materials, from delicate fabrics to thick leather, making it a versatile choice for various projects. Using the rotary blade, you can cut felt. In the Cricut Maker family, you can find the original Cricut Maker and the newer, faster Cricut Maker 3. Additionally, The Cricut Maker is compatible with the Design Space software, allowing users to create and customize their designs for cutting and crafting. This software can be used on a computer, tablet, or smartphone.
Since 2021, I’ve owned Cricut Maker for felt crafting and paper projects.
2. Sizzix Big Shot and its Capabilities
The Sizzix Big Shot is a manual cutting machine. This compact and versatile device is perfect for cutting various materials such as paper, cardstock, fabric, felt, etc. The Big Shot operates by using metal dies to cut the material, allowing for precise and intricate designs to be created effortlessly. One of its standout features is its exceptional embossing capabilities, which add an extra dimension to any project. Whether you're creating cards, scrapbooking, or working on home décor items, the Sizzix Big Shot is suitable for a wide range of crafting projects. The Big Shot also offers the flexibility to use dies and embossing folders from other brands.
I've crafted with Sizzix Big Shot since 2021. I use it for felt flowers and felt letters.
When it comes to comparing Cricut and Sizzix, there are several key differences to consider. The Cricut Maker is a digital cutting machine, while the Sizzix Big Shot is a manual machine that operates with the use of a handle. Additionally, Cricut utilizes software to design and create projects, while Sizzix uses dies to cut out shapes and designs. Cricut also features a cutting mat and rotary blade for precise cutting, while Sizzix uses a "sandwich" method of cutting with their manual machines. In terms of warranty, Cricut offers a 1-year limited warranty for their machines, while Sizzix offers a 3-year limited warranty on their products. Let's continue reading to learn more about these differences.
Electronic vs. Manual Die Cut Machine
The Cricut Maker is an electronic cutting machine, while the Sizzix Big Shot is a manual cutting machine. This means that the Cricut Maker operates using an electric motor and is controlled by software and digital files, allowing for precise and intricate cuts. On the other hand, the Sizzix Big Shot requires manual operation, as the user must physically crank the machine to cut through materials. The electronic nature of the Cricut Maker offers a wider range of customizable designs and options. In contrast, the manual Sizzix Big Shot requires dies to cut the design.
To conclude, the Cricut Maker provides a more advanced and diverse cutting experience, while the Sizzix Big Shot offers a more hands-on and traditional approach to crafting. From a durability perspective, the Cricut Maker is likely to have a shorter lifespan due to its electric motor and technological advancements. There is a higher chance that something might go wrong. In contrast, the Sizzix Big Shot is often considered more durable and reliable due to its lack of electronic components.
From my perspective, in the time I own the machines, I haven’t encountered any problem with either.
Manual Die Cut Machine Sizzix Big Shot
Digital Files (Cricut Design Space) vs. Dies
When it comes to crafting, the choice between using digital files and dies can greatly impact the versatility of a project. With the Sizzix Big Shot, the project is limited to the dies you have available, meaning you are restricted to the designs and shapes that are in your collection. On the other hand, with Cricut Design Space, you can easily adjust existing designs or create entirely new ones with ease, giving you a much wider range of possibilities. This flexibility allows for endless creativity and the ability to personalize and customize projects to your liking. Overall, while both methods have their unique advantages, the digital route provides more freedom and creativity in crafting.
With the dies, I enjoy the cut's speed and quality. However, If I get too enthusiastic, I can spend quite some money buying new dies for new projects. In the case of digital files, I like the versatility and the fact that I can change the design easily and fast to my liking.
Metal Die (BigZ) and Cutting Pads for Sizzix Big Shot
Comparison of Design Software and User Interface
Cricut Maker requires Cricut's Design Space to craft your projects, whereas Sizzix Big Shot doesn't need design software. Users simply select a die or embossing folder, place their material between the cutting pads, and then crank the machine to create their desired shape or texture. This is an important difference between the two machines.
Also, your device needs to fulfill minimum system requirements for Cricut Design Space to run effectively. It's a high-speed internet connection, RAM of 4GB, and 2 GB of free disk space, to name some. For all details, visit what system requirements you'll need for Design Space. This is important to consider as, in some cases, you might need to upgrade your device or internet speed.
In addition, consider if you're a person who likes to learn new software. Cricut Design Space isn't too difficult to work with, but you still need some time to invest in learning it.
To conclude, Sizzix Big Shot is easy to work with, whereas for Cricut Maker to work, you'll need to learn new software and potentially invest in upgrading your device and internet speed.
Cricut Design Space
Comparison of Warranty and Customer Support
Considering the warranty and customer support, both Cricut and Sizzix are dedicated to providing excellent assistance and backing for their machines.
Most of the Big Shot machines come with 1-year limited warranty as standard. This can be extended to 3 years, free of charge, by registering your machine on the Sizzix website. Cricut provides a 1-year warranty. Find more information on Cricut warranty.
As for customer service, I don't have any experience with Sizzix customer service as I didn't need it in more than 2 years that I have the machine. On the other hand, I had to contact Cricut once. They don't have any support in the Czech Republic, and I had to call the US. It was difficult to find the right time, considering the time difference. Also, I had to pay a considerable amount for the call. The problem was resolved, but it took some time. Some customers on the Internet complain of long waiting times when calling Cricut's customer support. This wasn't my case.
Sizzix Big Shot Pros
durability
ease of set up
ease of use - no technology to learn and no additional system requirement
cutting speed
cutting four layers of felt at the same time with BigZ dies
clean and sharp cuts
Sizzix Big Shot Cons
the shapes you can cut are limited by the dies available
new project, new investment into dies, this might become expensive
some Thinlits and Framelits die shapes don't cut felt well
cutting pads need to be replaced when worn out (this depends on the usage; with heavy usage, they last approximately 6 months)
Sizzix Big Shot - cutting felt shapes with Sizzix
Cricut Maker Pros
cut any shape as long as you have the design file or you find it in the projects library
design cut limited to 30" x 30" with Cricut Maker
can draw and cut in one operation
wide range of shapes and fonts that can be used to design your projects in Cricut Design space
lots of available projects in Cricut Design Space including projects from the Cricut's Community
Cricut Maker Cons
higher upfront cost
regular investment into new cutting mats
system requirements for your device and high-speed internet
learning the Cricut Design Space software that is needed to operate Cricut machines
has challenges with cutting tiny shapes of felt
finding the right settings for a perfect cut (blades, pressure, cutting mat)
cutting speed (though Cricut Maker 3 is twice as fast as Cricut Maker)
taking designs and residua off the cutting mat can be cumbersome
My Cricut Maker Die Cut Machine
Find a selection of my Cricut and Sizzix projects. As I craft with felt, these projects are felt crafts. I use my Cricut more than my Sizzix. This is due to the nature of my projects which are new felt craft patterns. This year I bought steel rule dies with the idea of using the Big Shot more, however didn't really got to it. And I consider the price of different dies high for how much I use them.
Creative Projects with Cricut
With Cricut, crafters can indulge in a wide array of creative projects, including personalized cards, home decor, and intricate paper crafts, thanks to its versatile cutting and writing capabilities. I made teacher cards and farewell gifts with Cricut and also paper Halloween decoration. As for felt crafts, most of my free felt patterns are cut with my Cricut Maker. Here I pick some:
Inspiring Projects with Sizzix
Sizzix machines are perfect for inspiring projects such as 3D designs, mixed media art, and stylish party decor, offering crafters the ability to create unique and eye-catching pieces.
DIY Felt Bunny Wall Decor (project where I used Cricut Maker and Sizzix Big Shot)
When deciding between Cricut and Sizzix for your die cutting needs, there are a few key factors to consider (discussed in detail in Differences between Cricut and Sizzix):
Firstly, take your initial budget and future investments into account. Cricut machines may have a higher initial cost and you should count with a regular investment into new cutting mats and potentially blades. Also, Cricut offers a wide range of accessories and materials that I want to have all :) and can add up over time. Sizzix machines, on the other hand, may have a lower upfront cost, but the cost of dies and embossing folders can add up as you expand your collection. Metal dies can be quite costly, especially larger background dies. You must consider whether you will use a die frequently enough to justify purchasing it.
Secondly, the quality of cuts made with a metal die is superior to those made with a Cricut.
Thirdly, a metal die has a fixed size, whereas a Cricut can cut the same image in various sizes depending on your needs.
Fourthly, with an electronic die cutting machine you have more creative options, but sometimes, it can be harder to get the settings right. For example, you need to select the right material (blade's pressure) depending on the type of felt you use (wool felt vs 100% PES felt).
Fifthly, don’t limit yourself to just Cricut. I’d look at the Silhouette Cameo as well. I don’t have Silhouette Cameo myself, so it’s difficult to compare Cricut to Silhouette, but I know some crafters prefer Silhouette Cameo over Cricut Maker.
Additionally, consider if you don't mind learning new software (Cricut Design Space). Cricut machines require the use of their Design Space software, while Sizzix Big Shot just needs your hands. For Design Space to run properly, ensure checking the system requirements and speed of internet.
Finally, consider if you do repetitive projects or if you try something new every time. Sizzix machines are known for their ease of use and ability to quickly replicate projects usizng the dies you have, while Cricut machines are popular among those who prefer to experiment and try new designs.
By taking these factors into consideration, you can make an informed decision on whether Cricut or Sizzix is the better fit for your die cutting needs.
Cricut vs Sizzix - My Die Cutting Machines
Interested in knowing how to use die cut machines to cut felt? Read the secrets and tips in How to cut felt using Sizzix and The ultimate guide to cutting felt with the Cricut machine.
Ultimately, both machines have pros and cons, and the choice between them ultimately depends on the individual's specific needs and priorities. So one cannot say what's the best die cutting machine. If precision cutting and versatility are the main concerns, then the Cricut Maker may be the better option. However, if cost and simplicity are more important factors, then the Sizzix Big Shot could be the preferred choice. Ultimately, it's important to carefully consider how each machine aligns with your crafting goals before deciding. It's also important to consider the availability of accessories and materials for each machine, as well as the level of customer support and community for each brand. It's a good idea to read reviews, watch tutorials, and even try out the machines, if possible, before making a decision.
Happy felt crafting!
If you want more inspiration for your felt crafting, head over to my Pinterest board Free Felt Patterns!
Be sure to visit more on this website for free embroidery and sewing tips & tricks to help you out as you stitch my patterns. For free felt patterns, visit my Freebies page.
Let's craft together!
XO, Anna